I like over-stuffed couches. I sampled both of these the other day, and I'll go with the blue one. Why do they call them over-stuffed? Most used furniture seems pretty much beat up and worn. If you are heading for one at a bar or coffee shop, you'll find cushions that have been dealt their u-shaped form by years upon years of big butt use. I can deal with the ill-formed cushions. However, it's the seats that exhibit that musty, peculiar aroma that you just can't place. Can't place, but you know it's not a good place. Both of these were free of such a malady. These couches have stories. I haven't read them yet though.